AAWE, Economics Dept, New York University, 19 W 4th St, 6Fl., New York NY 10012aawe@wine-economics.org

Pennsylvania Liquor Monopoly, AAWE Working Paper No. 69

Post 225 of 227

So maybe wine and liquor monopolies are not all bad!

At least that is the conclusion that Katja Seim and Joel Waldfogel arrive at in their recent

AAWE Working Paper No. 69 Economics

Public Monopoly and Economic Efficiency: Evidence from the Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board’s Entry Decisions

Katja Seim and Joel Waldfogel

They study the liquor control board in Pennsylvania, which is a monopoly provider of wine and spirits in that state. They conclude that a profit maximizing monopolist would have far fewer state stores than does the Pennsylvania authority–so maybe wine lovers don’t have as far to go as they might have otherwise had. At the same time, instead of locating adjacent to each other, as would occur in the usual world of unregulated free entry, state stores offer convenience to some far-flung locations that would not otherwise be served.

Still, the paper touches only on the aspects of monopoly that affect store locations–and I am betting that most Pennsylvania wine lovers have far bigger concerns than how far they have to drive to buy a bottle of chardonnay. What a lot of them would like to know is why do they have to drive at all? Wine lovers could shop online and have UPS do the driving, in which case store locations would be irrelevant! Shipping wine into Pennsylvania is, of course, illegal.

Moreover, since the Supreme Court compelled states to treat wineries in and out of state similarly, the Pennsylvania monopoly has gone a step farther–it now prohibits intra-state shipping from local, Pennsylvania producers too! Talk about shooting yourself in the foot.

OC Ashenfelter

This article was written by Karl Storchmann

3 comments:

AAWE #69 and #70 latest wine economics papers « Wine 2030 – University of AdelaideSeptember 1, 2010 at 8:16 pmReply

[…] AAWE President Orley Ashenfelter says that maybe this means that wine and liquor monopolies are not all bad! Read his blog here. […]

Isobel MadariagaDecember 3, 2011 at 4:08 pmReply

I have most certainly been involved with trading stocks and for more than ten years. I am an engaged individual in todays marketplace and my favorite main method is working with Option Trading Strategies. The current market has has proven by itself perfectly to me over the past number of years. Your posting agrees with my initial thoughts on the current market and appeared to be right on track. You did an excellent job of capturing the substance of your own point and driving it home. Investors and also seasoned traders alike really need to understand trading shares is an excellent vehicle to generate income. The recent market needs to be (and deserves to be) addressed with respect. Those which exploitation it will now unquestionably pay the piper ( or in this case the market maker). Option Trading Strategies should always be believed to be a part of every single individual strategy. Thank you and keep up these terrific reports!

LdrapesApril 16, 2012 at 11:30 pmReply

Thanks for the practical object.It took me a little time to uncover your site but it was worth the difficulties. It’s possible I will figure out how to use The search engines a little bit improved. Anyhow We stray by the main topic of astrology in addition to astrological readings. Thanks again in addition to happy blog.

Menu